Puzzlil vs Canva or InDesign for puzzle books

Canva and InDesign are design tools. You can make a puzzle book with them, but the puzzles, the layout and the answer key are all up to you. Puzzlil is built only for puzzle books.

FeaturePuzzlilCanva or InDesign
Where the puzzles come fromBuilt in: 21 types, each checked for one answerA separate generator or source, pasted in
Page layoutAutomatic, from KDP trim and marginsBy hand, page by page
Gutter for your page countSet and rechecked as pages changeYou look it up and set it
Answer keyBuilt at the back, numbered to matchMade and matched by hand
Cover spine widthFrom page count and paperWorked out by hand
General design freedomTemplates and settings for puzzle booksAnything you can design

What making a puzzle book in a design tool involves

First you need puzzles from somewhere: a generator website, a desktop program or your own work. Then you place each puzzle on a page at the right size, add page numbers and headings, and keep everything inside KDP's margins. The gutter has to grow as the page count grows.

Then you build the answer key: one solution for every puzzle, in the same order, labelled to match. If you change a puzzle, you change its answer too. Finally you work out the spine width and lay out the cover.

What Puzzlil does instead

You choose a trim size, add sections and set difficulty. Puzzlil generates the puzzles, checks each one, lays out every page, builds the answer key, keeps the page count even and checks the book against KDP's specs. Cover Studio sizes the cover from the real page count.

When a design tool is the better choice

If your book is mostly illustration, journaling or colouring pages with only a few puzzles, a design tool gives you more freedom. Puzzlil makes puzzles only. Some publishers use both: Puzzlil for the puzzle interior, a design tool for extra art.

Questions

Can I use Canva for my cover and Puzzlil for the interior?

Yes. Use the free cover size calculator for the exact cover size, or design the cover in Puzzlil's Cover Studio.

Can I edit Puzzlil's PDF in InDesign?

The export is a standard PDF. Most publishers upload it to KDP as it is.

Does Puzzlil do colouring pages?

No. It makes puzzles only.

Last updated